Judge Roy Bean
Judge Roy Bean

Movie spotlight

Judge Roy Bean

1971
Movie
91 min
Italian

In a small western town the ineffable judge Roy Bean metes out justice in his own special way. A cargo of gold is ambushed by the outlaw Black Bird who fails in the attempt and then rides into town.

Insights

IMDb6.2/10
Rotten Tomatoes50%
Google Users70%
Director: John MiliusGenres: Western, Comedy

Plot Summary

The film tells the story of Judge Roy Bean, a legendary and eccentric frontiersman who was the self-appointed "Hanging Judge" of Vinegaroon, Texas. He ruled the territory with an iron fist, dispensing his own brand of justice, often with the help of his pet grizzly bear, Bruno. Bean's life is a chaotic mix of lawlessness, bizarre trials, and his unrequited love for the beautiful singer Lily Langtry.

Critical Reception

Judge Roy Bean was met with mixed reviews. While Paul Newman's performance was widely praised, many critics found the film's tone to be uneven, veering between slapstick comedy and violent Western. The screenplay was also noted for its historical liberties and exaggerated portrayal of the real Judge Roy Bean.

What Reviewers Say

  • Praised Paul Newman's charismatic performance as the titular judge.

  • Criticized for its inconsistent tone and historical inaccuracies.

  • Found the blend of slapstick comedy and Western elements to be disjointed.

Google audience: Audiences generally found the film entertaining, largely due to Paul Newman's star power and the quirky premise. However, some viewers noted that the humor could be hit-or-miss and that the film didn't always live up to its potential.

Fun Fact

The film controversially depicted the real Judge Roy Bean as a murderer and rapist, a portrayal that was strongly disputed by historical accounts and Bean's descendants.

AI-generated overview · Verify ratings on official sources

My Review