Movie spotlight
Shiner
Raising the subtext of "Fight Club" into text, "Shiner" depicts a pair of amateur boxers gratified by punching each others' lights out. Theirs is among a trio of twisted love stories in the narrative feature by 29-year-old Los Angeles director Christian Calson. There's also a woman literally fighting her male lover's affections and another boxer who stalks his own shy male stalker. "Shiner" transcends sadomasochism in that no one seems aware of what he or she is doing. "I'm trying to look at desire head on," the soft-spoken Calson said by telephone. "('Shiner') is about the politics of wanting and being wanted and how people respond differently." Rife with ugly behavior, "Shiner" rejects the trend of queer filmmakers seeking straight understanding. "In L.A., we have this kind of sadness we carry around, that the only way we can make gay stories is by making more like 'Will and Grace,' " Calson said. Like the activist-filmmakers tackling the marriage issue, Calson went into "...
Insights
Plot Summary
A veteran enforcer for a powerful triad boss is released from prison and finds himself caught between his loyalty to his boss and his desire for a normal life. He becomes entangled with a young woman who dreams of escaping the criminal underworld. As he tries to protect her and find redemption, he must confront his past and the dangerous consequences of his choices.
Critical Reception
Shiner was generally well-received by critics for its stylish direction, strong performances, and compelling blend of action and drama. It is considered a solid entry in Johnnie To's prolific filmography, praised for its gritty portrayal of Hong Kong's criminal underworld.
What Reviewers Say
Praised for its intense action sequences and dramatic depth.
Andy Lau's performance as the conflicted enforcer is a standout.
Offers a gritty and authentic look at triad life in Hong Kong.
Google audience: Information on Google user reviews for 'Shiner (2004)' is not readily available.
Fun Fact
The film is noted for its realistic depiction of the internal workings and social codes of Hong Kong's Triad societies, reflecting Johnnie To's deep research into the subject matter.
AI-generated overview · Verify ratings on official sources