Movie spotlight
Mercy or Murder?
Roswell and Emily Gilbert were married for fifty-one years, but for the eight final years of their marriage Emily suffered from Alzheimer's disease and the bone disease osteoporosis. Often in pain, Emily begged to die. In March 1985, 75-year-old Roswell shot Emily in the head. He said it was an act of mercy, but he was tried for murder and convicted as the nation debated euthanasia.
Insights
Plot Summary
A young lawyer takes on the controversial case of a woman accused of murdering her husband. As she delves deeper into the evidence and the victim's past, she uncovers a complex web of deceit, abuse, and potential self-defense. The film explores the moral ambiguities surrounding the case and the legal system's struggle to determine true guilt or justifiable homicide.
Critical Reception
This made-for-television drama was met with mixed reviews, with some critics praising its exploration of complex themes and Susan Dey's performance, while others found the plot predictable and the execution somewhat formulaic.
What Reviewers Say
Praised for its thought-provoking examination of domestic abuse and legal ethics.
Criticized for its adherence to common television movie tropes.
Susan Dey's performance was often highlighted as a strong point.
Google audience: Information on specific Google user reviews for this 1987 television film is not readily available.
Fun Fact
The film was based on the real-life case of Candy Montgomery, though the names and some details were altered for the production.
AI-generated overview · Verify ratings on official sources