Should Tall Men Marry?
Should Tall Men Marry?

Movie spotlight

Should Tall Men Marry?

1928
Movie
20 min
English

This western comedy is about rancher Finlayson's beautiful daughter, Martha Sleeper, who refuses to marry the bad guy and how Jimmy and dimwitted cowhand Stan bumble their way into a successful defense of her and the ranch.

Insights

IMDb6.7/10
Director: Leo McCareyGenres: Comedy, Short, Romance

Plot Summary

This short comedy follows the misadventures of a young man who is concerned about his height and its implications for marriage. He encounters various situations and characters that highlight societal expectations and personal insecurities surrounding height differences in relationships. The film playfully explores the idea of whether height should be a deciding factor in who one chooses to marry.

Critical Reception

As a short comedy from the silent era, contemporary critical reception focused on its comedic elements and the performance of its lead. It is generally remembered as a lighthearted and amusing piece that played on popular notions of the time.

What Reviewers Say

  • Praised for its lighthearted humor and playful premise.

  • Eddie Cantor's comedic timing is a highlight.

  • Offers a charming, if simple, look at societal dating norms of the era.

Google audience: Audience reviews for this silent short are scarce, but those available often note its dated humor and nostalgic appeal. Viewers tend to appreciate its historical context and the earnest performance of Eddie Cantor.

Fun Fact

This film marked one of Leo McCarey's earliest directorial efforts, showcasing his nascent talent for comedy that would later define much of his career.

AI-generated overview · Verify ratings on official sources

My Review