The Disputation
The Disputation

Movie spotlight

The Disputation

1986
Movie
65 min
English

In 1263, King James I of Aragon organizes a debate between representatives of Judaism and Christianity regarding whether or not Jesus was the Messiah.

Insights

IMDb7.1/10
Director: Norman JewisonGenres: Drama

Plot Summary

A group of scholars is assembled to arbitrate a dispute between a distinguished scientist and his former protégé, who accuses the scientist of plagiarism. As the investigation unfolds, deeply personal secrets and professional rivalries come to the surface, challenging the very nature of truth and integrity within the academic community.

Critical Reception

The Disputation received mixed to positive reviews, with particular praise for its intellectual rigor and strong performances, especially from Christopher Plummer. Some critics found the pacing deliberate, but most acknowledged its compelling exploration of ethical dilemmas in science.

What Reviewers Say

  • Praised for its intelligent script and intense dialogue.

  • Christopher Plummer's performance was widely lauded as commanding.

  • Some viewers found the film's philosophical discussions challenging.

  • The exploration of academic ethics and personal betrayal was a common theme in reviews.

Google audience: Audience reception information is not readily available for this specific television film.

Awards & Accolades

Christopher Plummer won a Gemini Award for Best Performance by a Lead Actor in a Dramatic Program or Series for his role in 'The Disputation'.

Fun Fact

The film was originally a stage play by Canadian playwright Albert M. Johnson before being adapted for television.

AI-generated overview · Verify ratings on official sources

My Review