When Women Lie
When Women Lie

Movie spotlight

When Women Lie

1963
Movie
93 min
Japanese

Three stories about the relationship between men and women: "Playgirl" (Masumura/Shirasaka), "Company No. 2" (Yoshimura/Kasahara), and "San Nyotai" (Kinugasa/Shindô).

Insights

IMDb6.5/10
Director: Edward DmytrykGenres: Drama, Mystery, Thriller

Plot Summary

A young, beautiful woman, seemingly naive and innocent, finds herself entangled in a complex web of deceit and manipulation after being accused of a crime. As the investigation unfolds, layers of her past and her relationships are revealed, blurring the lines between victim and perpetrator. The film explores themes of societal judgment, hidden desires, and the true nature of guilt.

Critical Reception

When Women Lie received mixed reviews upon its release. While some critics praised its atmospheric tension and Carroll Baker's performance, others found the plot convoluted and its themes underdeveloped. Audience reception was similarly divided, with some drawn to its melodrama and others put off by its perceived sensationalism.

What Reviewers Say

  • Praised for its stylish direction and Carroll Baker's compelling performance.

  • Criticized for a convoluted plot that struggles to maintain narrative coherence.

  • Some found the film's exploration of its themes to be superficial.

Google audience: Audience reviews are scarce, but general sentiment suggests a film that is visually interesting but narratively flawed, leaving many viewers with a sense of dissatisfaction.

Fun Fact

Carroll Baker's character in the film, Brenda, is often seen as a complex figure that challenged the typical portrayal of female characters in films of the early 1960s, hinting at deeper psychological complexities than typically presented.

AI-generated overview · Verify ratings on official sources

My Review