

A Promise to Carolyn
When two sisters can no longer go on living with the painful memory of their baby sister being murdered 37 years ago by their stepmother, together they try to uncover the truth.
Insights
Plot Summary
This docudrama tells the true story of Carolyn Weatherford, a woman who struggles to come to terms with her husband's secret life as a serial killer. After years of denial and confusion, Carolyn must confront the horrifying reality and decide how to protect herself and her family.
Critical Reception
While specific critical reviews from 1996 are scarce, "A Promise to Carolyn" is generally remembered as a compelling and disturbing made-for-television movie that effectively portrays the psychological toll of living with a serial killer. It is noted for its strong lead performance and its sensitive handling of a difficult subject matter.
What Reviewers Say
- A chilling portrayal of a woman's unwitting complicity.
- Meredith Baxter delivers a powerful and nuanced performance.
- Explores the dark psychological complexities of domestic abuse and deception.
Google audience: Audience reception is difficult to quantify due to the film's age and TV movie status, but it is often cited as a memorable and impactful drama for its time.
Fun Fact
The film is based on the real-life story of Carolyn Weatherford and her husband, serial killer Billy "The Hillside Strangler" Cook.
AI-generated overview · Verify ratings on official sources