This documentary delves into the urban legend of Cropsey, a boogeyman figure in Staten Island folklore. Directors Barbara Brancaccio and Joshua Zeman investigate the true story behind the legend, exploring its connection to a series of child disappearances and murders on Staten Island. The film uncovers disturbing truths and raises questions about justice and the nature of evil.

Cropsey received generally positive reviews from critics, who praised its unsettling atmosphere and its effective blend of true crime and horror documentary elements. While some found the pacing uneven, many commended the filmmakers for their thorough investigation and for shedding light on a dark chapter of local history.

• A chilling and disturbing exploration of a local urban legend intertwined with real-life tragedy.
• Effectively builds suspense and raises unsettling questions about the nature of fear and crime.
• Praised for its investigative journalism and its ability to create a palpable sense of dread.

Google audience: Audiences found the documentary to be a compelling and disturbing look at the Cropsey legend, with many appreciating the filmmakers' dedication to uncovering the truth behind the unsettling events. Some viewers noted that the film can be quite graphic and disturbing due to its subject matter.

The documentary was inspired by a childhood fear that director Barbara Brancaccio had of the Cropsey boogeyman, which she shared with co-director Joshua Zeman.