By Whose Hand?

A wealthy industrialist is murdered, and the police investigate a complex web of potential suspects. Among them is the victim's estranged wife, his ambitious business partner, and a mysterious stranger with a hidden motive. As the investigation unfolds, secrets and lies come to light, leading to a dramatic revelation of the killer's identity.

As a silent film from the late 1920s, detailed critical reception is scarce. However, surviving reviews and its classification as a mystery point to it being a standard, albeit perhaps unremarkable, genre piece for its time, relying on suspense and a convoluted plot to engage audiences.

• A standard mystery thriller typical of the era.

• Relies on a complex plot and a series of red herrings.

• A serviceable crime drama with a surprising, albeit perhaps convoluted, conclusion.

Google audience: Information on Google user reviews for this silent film is not available.

This film is notable for featuring a very young Walter Pidgeon in one of his early roles, years before he became a major Hollywood star.