Movie spotlight
Is This Reasonable?
A young journalist comes from Nice to Paris to meet with the famous judge, Simon, hoping he will help her understand a case. She does not know that, according to the will of fate, in the office of judge was fugitive criminal. The couple hit the road.
Insights
Plot Summary
This short documentary explores the concept of 'reasonableness' within the legal system, examining how it is applied in court cases. Director Jonathan Miller interviews legal professionals and presents case examples to dissect the subjective nature of what constitutes reasonable behavior or belief. The film aims to provoke thought about the complexities and potential biases inherent in legal judgments.
Critical Reception
As a short documentary from 1981, specific widespread critical reception is difficult to ascertain. However, Jonathan Miller's work generally earned praise for its intellectual rigor and accessible presentation of complex subjects. It is likely that "Is This Reasonable?" was seen as an insightful and thought-provoking examination of a fundamental legal principle.
What Reviewers Say
Praised for its intelligent exploration of legal subjectivity.
Appreciated for making a complex legal concept understandable.
Noted for Jonathan Miller's insightful and engaging presentation.
Google audience: Audience reception for this specific short documentary is not widely documented.
Fun Fact
Jonathan Miller, a polymath known for his work as a comedian, director, writer, and physician, brought his characteristic wit and sharp intellect to this exploration of legal reasoning.
AI-generated overview · Verify ratings on official sources