Elliot Sherman is a 'nice guy' in New York City, known for his agreeable nature and inability to say no. This characteristic earns him the unwanted label of 'baxter,' a term used to describe a man who is always available to do favors but never the one chosen for romance. Elliot finds himself constantly helping others, including his boss, his best friend, and even his crush, Caroline, who is dating his friend. His life takes a turn when he meets a new colleague, who challenges his passive nature and encourages him to stand up for himself and pursue what he truly wants.

The Baxter received a mixed to positive reception from critics, who often praised its charm and the performances of its lead actors, particularly Michelle Williams. However, some reviewers found the premise to be a bit too niche and the humor occasionally predictable, though many appreciated its gentle and sweet romantic comedy approach.

• Praised for its endearing performances and heartfelt romantic storyline.
• Some critics found the central concept to be a bit too understated or the humor to be hit-or-miss.
• Generally viewed as a charming, albeit somewhat quirky, romantic comedy.

Google audience: Audience reviews often highlight the film's sweetness and the likability of its main characters, finding it a charming and relatable romantic comedy, though some wished for more laugh-out-loud moments.

The term 'baxter' was coined by the film's writer and director, Michael Showalter, based on a friend he knew who fit the description.