The Prisoner of Second Avenue
The Prisoner of Second Avenue

Movie spotlight

The Prisoner of Second Avenue

1975
Movie
98 min
English

Mel Edison has just lost his job after many years and now has to cope with being unemployed at middle age during an intense NYC heat wave.

Insights

IMDb6.5/10
Director: Vincente MinnelliGenres: Comedy, Drama

Plot Summary

Melvin, a middle-aged man recently fired from his job and suffering from a nervous breakdown, is struggling to cope with the harsh realities of New York City life. His wife, Edna, is forced to work to support them, leading to increasing tension and communication breakdowns between the couple. Melvin's mental state deteriorates as he faces unemployment, loneliness, and the general chaos of his urban surroundings.

Critical Reception

The film adaptation of Neil Simon's popular play received mixed reviews, with praise often directed at Jack Lemmon's performance but criticism leveled at the adaptation process and the perceived datedness of the material. Audiences were divided, with some appreciating the comedic elements and relatable themes of urban alienation, while others found it less engaging than the stage version.

What Reviewers Say

  • Jack Lemmon's performance as the increasingly unhinged Melvin is a standout, capturing the character's despair and comedic potential.

  • The film struggles to translate the tight, witty dialogue of the stage play to the screen, losing some of its original impact.

  • While relatable in its themes of urban stress and job loss, the humor occasionally feels forced and the overall tone can be uneven.

Google audience: Audience reception information is not readily available.

Awards & Accolades

None notable.

Fun Fact

The film is based on the 1971 Neil Simon play of the same name, which was a critical and commercial success on Broadway.

AI-generated overview · Verify ratings on official sources

My Review