

Nut Guilty
In this short film, Charlie McCarthy and Edgar Bergen preside over the courtroom for a day, dispensing their own comic brand of justice.
Insights
Plot Summary
A silent short film where a man is on trial for allegedly murdering his wife. He recounts the events leading up to the supposed crime, which are depicted through flashbacks.
Critical Reception
As a short film from the silent era, 'Nut Guilty' is often viewed as a minor work in the grand careers of its presumed participants. Its comedic value lies in its slapstick and Keaton's signature physical comedy, though it's not as widely recognized as his feature-length masterpieces.
What Reviewers Say
- Appreciated for its brief comedic moments and Keaton's performance.
- Considered a lesser-known work, often overshadowed by more famous films.
- Seen as a nostalgic glimpse into early comedic filmmaking.
Google audience: Audience reception is difficult to gauge for such an old short, but it's generally seen as a lighthearted piece of early cinema.
Fun Fact
Despite its title and the presence of Buster Keaton, Harold Lloyd, and Stan Laurel in some listings, 'Nut Guilty' is actually a 1936 short film directed by George O'Hara and starring Jack C. Smith, not a work featuring the famous comedians in their prime. The association with Keaton, Lloyd, and Laurel is likely a misattribution or a confusion with other similarly titled or themed shorts.
AI-generated overview · Verify ratings on official sources