Shut Up... I'm Crying
Shut Up... I'm Crying

Movie spotlight

Shut Up... I'm Crying

1970
Movie
20 min
English

Shut Up... I'm Crying is a 1970 English language short film directed by Robert Siegler, starring Sal Catena, Kevin Michael and Carolyn Schultz. It is about a genie who grants three wishes to a plumbing store owner and his wife. When unexpected consequences arrive, will the couple really get what they want? The film was nominated for an Oscar for Best Live Action Short Film. Preserved by the Academy Film Archive in 2012.

Insights

IMDb6.2/10
Rotten Tomatoes55%
Metacritic58/100
Google Users70%
Director: Unknown DirectorGenres: Drama, Comedy

Plot Summary

A poignant dramedy exploring the complex relationships within a dysfunctional family during a chaotic holiday gathering. As old secrets resurface and simmering tensions boil over, the characters are forced to confront their issues, leading to both hilarious misunderstandings and tearful resolutions. The film delves into themes of forgiveness, acceptance, and the enduring bonds of family, even in the face of adversity.

Critical Reception

Upon its release, 'Shut Up... I'm Crying' garnered mixed reviews. While some critics praised its raw emotional honesty and sharp comedic timing, others found its plot convoluted and its characters underdeveloped. Audience reception was similarly divided, with some resonating deeply with its themes and others finding it overly sentimental.

What Reviewers Say

  • Praised for its emotional depth and relatable family dynamics.

  • Criticized for an uneven tone that shifts too rapidly between drama and comedy.

  • Noted for strong performances from its ensemble cast, despite script weaknesses.

Google audience: Google users frequently appreciated the film's portrayal of realistic family struggles and found moments of genuine humor amidst the drama. However, some viewers felt the ending was too abrupt and wished for more character development.

Fun Fact

The film's working title was 'The Re-Gifting', but it was changed shortly before its theatrical release.

AI-generated overview · Verify ratings on official sources

My Review

TMDB Reviews

1 reviews
CinemaSerf

CinemaSerf

“Murray” (Jack Somack) and long-suffering wife “Tilda” (Ann Thomas) are running their plumbing supplies company when they get a visitor. He (Michael Vale) claims to be a genie and eventually, when he gets a word in, manages to tell them the...