IMDb6.1/10
Google Users65%
Director: Charles Vidor•Genres: Drama, Romance, War
During World War I, a British ambulance driver serving in the Italian army falls in love with a compassionate English nurse. Their passionate romance blossoms amidst the brutal realities of war and the chaos of the Italian front. As their relationship deepens, they face immense challenges, including separation, injury, and the ever-present threat of the conflict.
The 1957 adaptation of Ernest Hemingway's novel received a mixed to negative reception from critics, with many finding it overly sentimental and a poor representation of Hemingway's stark prose. While the performances of the lead actors were sometimes praised, the film was largely criticized for its deviations from the source material and its melodramatic tone. Audiences also seemed divided, with some appreciating the romantic storyline and others finding it lacking the emotional depth of the novel.
Praised for the chemistry between Rock Hudson and Jennifer Jones.
Criticized for being overly sentimental and diverging from Hemingway's original tone.
Found to be a visually grand but emotionally hollow adaptation.
Google audience: Audience reviews suggest a divided opinion, with some viewers appreciating the romantic drama and the performances of the lead actors. However, a significant portion of viewers felt the film was too melodramatic and a disappointing adaptation of the classic novel.
This was the second major Hollywood adaptation of Ernest Hemingway's novel, following a 1932 version starring Gary Cooper and Helen Hayes.
AI-generated overview · Verify ratings on official sources