Her Cardboard Lover

In this comedic melodrama, a wealthy woman named Terry Parton, fearing her lover will leave her for a younger woman, devises a scheme to keep him interested. She enlists her friend, the poet Charlie Dunhill, to pose as her "cardboard lover" and make her possessive fiance jealous. However, the plan takes an unexpected turn when Terry finds herself developing genuine feelings for Charlie, leading to a complex love triangle.

Her Cardboard Lover was met with a lukewarm reception upon its release. While the performances of the lead actors were sometimes praised, the film's plot was often criticized for being contrived and lacking the sharp wit expected from its comedic premise and director. Audience reception was similarly mixed, with many finding the story overly melodramatic and the comedic elements not fully realized.

• The film struggles to balance its comedic aspirations with its dramatic elements, resulting in a uneven tone.
• While the actors deliver decent performances, the plot is often seen as predictable and lacking depth.
• The central premise, though potentially interesting, is not fully exploited, leading to a less engaging experience.

Google audience: Audience reviews for 'Her Cardboard Lover' are scarce due to its age and limited distribution history. However, what limited feedback is available suggests a divided audience, with some appreciating the classic Hollywood charm and performances, while others found the plot to be dated and unconvincing.

The play 'Her Cardboard Lover' was based on the French play 'The Detective' by Ferenc Molnár, which had previously been adapted into a silent film in 1924 starring Adolphe Menjou and Lilyan Tashman.