Why Not?
Why Not?

Why Not?

1981Movie151 minJapanese

The film depicts carnivalesque atmosphere summed up by the cry "Ei ja nai ka" ("Why not?") in Japan in 1867 and 1868 in the days leading to the Meiji Restoration. It examines the effects of the political and social upheaval of the time, and culminates in a revelrous march on the Tokyo Imperial Palace, which turns into a massacre. Characteristically, Imamura focuses not on the leaders of the country, but on characters in the lower classes and on the fringes of society.

Read Reviews

Insights

IMDb5.4/10
Director: René ManzorGenres: Horror, Thriller

Plot Summary

A disgraced policeman, haunted by the murder of his wife and child, takes on a dangerous mission to rescue a young girl kidnapped by a ruthless criminal gang. He must confront his own demons and navigate a treacherous underworld where survival is far from guaranteed. The film explores themes of revenge, justice, and the thin line between sanity and madness.

Critical Reception

Critically, 'Why Not?' (also known as 'Le Chacal d'or') garnered a mixed to negative reception upon its release. While some critics acknowledged its grim atmosphere and a few intense moments, many found the plot convoluted and the violence excessive without sufficient narrative justification. Audience reception was similarly divided, with some appreciating its raw, gritty feel and others put off by its bleakness and perceived lack of coherence.

What Reviewers Say

  • Presents a bleak and violent narrative that some viewers found compelling, while others criticized its lack of depth.
  • The film's grim atmosphere and focus on brutal action were polarizing.
  • Often cited for its convoluted plot and gratuitous violence.

Google audience: Audience reviews for 'Why Not?' are scarce and generally indicate a film that failed to connect with a broad audience. Those who appreciated it often pointed to its dark tone and the intensity of its action sequences. However, a significant portion of viewers found the film to be nonsensical, overly violent, and ultimately unsatisfying.

Awards & Accolades

None notable.

Fun Fact

The film was controversially banned in several countries due to its graphic content and themes at the time of its release.

AI-generated overview · Verify ratings on official sources

My Review